1. From the perspective of Piaget's theory, in which stage of cognitive development is Laura? Justify your response.
Laura is still in the preoperational stage of cognitive development. In this stage, Piaget says that children can think about objects and events beyond their immediate view, but do not yet reason in logical, adultlike ways. Laura has a limited amount of knowledge about pollution and its harm, and is hypothesizing theories that are not at all practical. At the end of this case study, Laura says that Mr. Marculescu is being unreasonable, and therefore, she could not yet be in the concrete operational stage becuase if she was, she would realize that her own perspectives and feelings may be different from others. In the concrete operational stage, Piaget also theorizes that adultlike logic appears, and in Laura's situation, that is clearly not the case. Laura does not realize how difficult it would be if her theory was actually put into action, and she had to physically carry her trash to a landfill and walk everywhere, every day.
2. How is Laura's reasoning affected by her knowledge base--that is, by what she does and doesn't know about pollution?
Laura has a limited amount of knowledge about pollution. She knows it is harmful, and she knows that gasoline is a large contributor to air pollution. Laura is only 14 years old, and so she obviously does not have her license yet. Laura does not understand or realize how difficult life would become if no one could buy gasoline. The entire world would come to a halt, and we would have to find alternative ways to perform crucial tasks, like delivering food to grocery stores. Laura has not considered other methods to decrease air pollution that may not have such a drastic affect on the community.
3. By posing a series of questions, Mr. Marculescu continually challenges Laura to reconsider her thinking about the pollution problem. What are potential benefits of this strategy? Use terminology from Piaget's and Vygotsky's theories in your response.
By asking questions repeatedly, Mr. Marculsecu forced Laura to think deeper into her theory and to look at multiple components, which she had not thought about before. This represents Vygostsky's zone of proximal development; I do, we do, you do. The teacher was much more knowledgeable about pollution than Laura, and was guiding her to think more logically. Vygotsky also claims that children’s complex thought processes have roots in social interaction. Once children discuss or debate challenging issues with more competent individuals, they will eventually take what they have learned, internalize it, add their own thoughts and opinions on the matter, and begin to use these tools in the real world.
Mr. Marculescu is also using Piaget's assimilation and accommodation. He used assimilation by discussing a topic that is relevant to the students, and one that the students should have prior knowledge about. He used accommodation by giving the students additional factors to consider while solving the pollution problem, and therefore was able to use equilibration. By the end of the debate on this particular topic, the students will have grown cognitively.
4. How does this scenario represent Piaget's and Vygotsky's conceptions of play?
From Piaget's point of view, kids develop cognitively most effectively during independent play and active learning. Mr. Marulescu gave Laura that opportunity by asking her challenging questions, and making her stand up in front of the class. Laura was forced to reason with his questions and find her own opinion about the pollution problem.
According to Vygostsky, play enables children to stretch cognitively, and while in play, "a child is always above his average age, above his daily behavior, in play it is as though he were a head taller than himself." In Laura's situation, she was acting as a spokesperson and offering her own opinion of how today's pollution problem should be solved. She was forced to think outside of her comfort zone and with the gentle guidance and prompting of her teacher, she was given the opportunity to consider things she would not have thought about before. Mr. Marculescu provided his students with the chance to "play" in order to prepare them for the adult world and help them consider real issues.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment