Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Ch. 6 Case Study Analysis

Case 1:

1. After participating in this activity of re-enacting the Civil War, the students will remember much more than they would have by simply reading about it in a book or taking notes from a lecture. The students will remember how early they had to wake up, how tiring the long march was carrying heavy battle gear, how difficult it was to set up camp, and how long it took to cook dinner over a campfire. By having these experiences, the students were given the opportunity to engage their emotions into the learning process. By engaging experience and emotion, the students are going to store this new information in their long-term memory. The students will remember way more from this experience than they ever would have if they had only learned about it in class.

2. This re-enactment engages the student’s emotions in many ways. Because this was an all day activity, the students probably experienced a wide variety of emotions including excitement, curiosity, stress, and fatigue. The emotions that these students felt are each tied hand in hand with specific sensations, IE; hunger, exhaustion, sore muscles and body pains, etc. The learning these students attained will now tie directly into an experience they had for the rest of their lives. These experiences had a tangible product that these students could relate to and remember; blisters, being sore, feeling hunger and having to prepare their own food unconventionally. This learning experience can be compared to the learning of how a food tastes. For someone who has never tasted a specific food, it is very difficult to explain how that food tastes. Whereas in an instant they can experience the taste of that food and feel the sensations and emotions tied into the taste of it, which will instill within them the experience of it. The emotions tied to this learning will prove to be remembered much easier than the explanations of how that food tastes. Likewise, the experience that these students had and the emotions that they felt, will serve these students well.

3. To help his students better understand and retain the memories of the experience that they had, Mr. West could reinforce teaching to them what they learned with any of several kinds of different activities with the students. One example would be for the students to then record a journal entry of their day, writing down the specific emotions that they felt and perhaps brainstorming how much harder that would have been for the real soldiers who lived like this on a daily basis without relief. Mr. West now would be ultimately effective with his teachings if he afterwards followed up by having his students remember their experiences, and write them down or experience them again in a new way. This allows the students to imagine more of what these situations would have really been like, which in turn could help these students better understand what the soldiers were going through.

Case 2:

4. I think Mr. Richards definitely provides better instruction for his students. If students always know what to expect like they do in Mr. Dunkin's class, the students will get into a routine where they will only study (most likely cram) for the Friday quizzes. The students will figure out what information they need to store until they are tested on it and what information they can simply bypass. In Mr. Richard’s class, he is engaging the student’s minds in many different ways and creating multiple pathways to connect information. Since there are pop quizzes, the students will be continuously studying the material, which will be stored in their long-term memory since cramming will not be involved. No two people learn the same exact way and Mr. Richards is well aware of that. He is making the students think about and process the class information in a variety of ways.

5. The way the learning outcomes would differ between the two classes is that the students in Mr. Richard's class would have a greater understanding of the course content. These students were required to understand all the concepts they were taught because they were given pop quizzes. They would never know when they would be tested on the information, so their current understanding and studying of the course material was crucial. The students in Mr. Dunkin's class were only taught in one way, through lecture and personal study. If these students were not linguistic learners, and most are not, then they were not gaining a full understanding of the material. Only one pathway was being engaged in Mr. Dunkin's class. The students in Mr. Richard's class are more likely to store and maintain the information in their long-term memory.

No comments:

Post a Comment