1. Does Mr. Kessinger's class represent a community of learners as defined in Ch. 7? Why or why not?
No, Mr. Kessigner’s class does not represent a community of learners. The teacher is discourteous and intimidating, so students are probably scared to work together or ask Mr. Kessinger for help on anything they may not understand because “they are expected to know it before class.” Because Mr. Kessinger demands this, his students are learning the material individually rather than together. If his class did represent a community of learners, he would want to learn and grow with his students. It sounds like Mr. Kessinger is on a “power trip” and expects way too much out of his twelfth graders. The definition of community of learners says “a class in which teacher and students actively and collaboratively work to help one another learn and succeed.” To me, it does not sound like Mr. Kessinger truly cares if his students succeed or not.
2. Does Mr. Kessinger utilize presentation punishment or removal punishment with Robin? Justify your response.
Mr. Kessinger utilizes presentation punishment with Robin. The teacher yelled at Robin and humiliated her in front of the entire class, which Robin was not expecting. She did not know she was doing anything wrong and was shocked to discover the result of her innocent concept map. Robin had put in a lot of time and energy into enhancing her understanding of class concepts, but the teacher only saw it as cheating. Mr. Kessinger’s presentation of punishment was yelling at Robin, which resulted in Robin never taking notes again in his class. This was a big mistake on Mr. Kessinger’s part because he discouraged Robin from doing what she needs to do to learn most effectively.
3. Explain Robin's reaction in Ms. Yamashita's class from the perspective of classical conditioning.
Robin had been humiliated and emotionally hurt in her previous class, so once she got to Ms. Yamashita’s class, she was not thinking clearly. When Robin opened her psychology notebook, her mind was on autopilot and she was not consciously thinking about the consequence she received for having notes in Mr. Kessinger’s class. Before she remembered she might get in trouble again for having a concept map, Ms. Yamashita was towering over her looking at her notes. Robin panicked and did not correctly interpret the nice comments her teacher said about her concept map. Robin only made the connection between her notes and the teacher standing directly in front of her, which involuntarily triggered the same emotional response she felt in her earlier class. Robin had quickly learned that having notes are “bad” and she should hide them from the teacher in order not to get in trouble.
4. How might Ms. Yamashita encourage Robin to create concept maps in the future? Include behavioral concepts such as shaping, reinforcement, etc., in your response.
Ms. Yamashita did the right thing to encourage Robin to create concept maps in the future by telling her how great her work was and that she wanted to copy it so the entire class could follow her example. If Robin had heard that properly rather than running to the bathroom and crying, she would already have been feeling better about her notes. One way the teacher could encourage Robin to create concept maps in the future is by having it be part of a token economy. Ms. Yamashita could tell the students that any time they have proof that they did something extra to increase their own learning of concepts, they could receive tokens to be earned for a special reward. Because Robin likes to please her teachers, I think she would really enjoy that. The teacher could also offer reinforcement for anything students do well, like participating in class discussions, getting a good grade on a quiz or test, helping another student with their homework, or like Robin did, create something to increase their understanding of a topic. As long as Ms. Yamashita makes it clear that she likes her students to be proactive on their homework and in class discussions, I think Robin will quickly reverse her classical conditioning response and revert to being an excellent student.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment