Thursday, December 10, 2009

Ch. 11/12 Case Study Extra Credit

1. Does William have a mastery goal or a performance goal in his art class? Justify your response.

In this case study, William definitely has a performance goal rather than a mastery goal. If William had a mastery goal, he would only be concerned about what he learned from earlier art projects and how he has grown from his past mistakes. Instead, William is only concerned about what others will think of him once he submits his artwork, namely his teacher and peers. The book's definition of performance goal is "the desire to demonstrate high ability and make a good impression." William obviously does not have high self-efficacy in his art work, nor does he think his work would make a good impression and that is why he has not turned anything in the entire semester.

2. How would you best characterize William's attribution? (Internal/External, Controllable/Uncontrollable, Stable/Unstable) Use specific examples from the text to justify your response.

I would characterize William's attribution as internal/external locus. Contrary to what we learned in class today, which is that usually women blame themselves for dissatisfying work and men blame others, William is completely blaming himself for his "less than perfect" artwork. In the case study William says, "But my best is never good enough. I'm not good at art. I don't want the other kids to see how bad I really am." William thinks his classmates work is almost perfect and his should be too in order to show it to others.

3. Are Mr. Mercurio's teaching strategies likely to promote performance goals or mastery goals? Justify your response. What more might Mr. Mercurio do to help William and other students like him?

Mr. Mercurios's teaching strategies are likely to promote mastery goals. I believe this because he tells William several times that he does not need to be a perfectionist and if he tries to do so, he will not succeed in the class. The teacher also tells William that being a good artist takes practice and he should learn from his mistakes rather than be ashamed of them. Mr. Mercurio could better help William and other similar students by encouraging them with positive remarks, giving grades on harder projects just for effort, and letting the students work on certain art projects with partners in order to see how other students conduct their skills.

4. Describe some needs that William seems to have. How might those needs be better met in Mr. Mercurio's classroom?

According to Maslow's Hierarchy of needs, I think William is on level four of the pyramid, esteem needs. I believe William has his physiological needs met, probably feels safe at home and in school, and probably has a positive home life where he feels love and belonging. I assume this because in the case study, it says William was given chores, which means his parents care enough about him to help him develop skills in the home. William simply has not developed esteem and does not feel he has high achievements, status, or responsibility in art. Mr. Mercurio could help William develop this need in the classroom by giving William positive reinforcement and letting him work with other students on art projects so he can at least finish a few assignments before the end of the semester in order not to fail the class.

No comments:

Post a Comment